Edinburgh is really two cities sharing one skyline. On the volcanic rock above, the medieval Old Town: the castle, the Royal Mile, closes and wynds that have barely changed in four centuries. Below and to the north, the Georgian New Town: wide streets, crescents, and garden squares laid out when Edinburgh decided to become the Athens of the North. The two halves together are a UNESCO World Heritage Site, and almost everything you’ll want to see sits within walking distance of both.
Planning a trip? Get our free Travel Planning Checklist:
Where you stay shapes the trip more here than in most cities, because the neighborhoods have such different personalities — steep and atmospheric, or calm and elegant, or waterfront and food-obsessed. Here’s my breakdown of the six areas worth considering, with hotel picks for every budget and the honest trade-offs of each.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you book through one of these links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Old Town — the first-timer’s pick
If it’s your first visit, stay in the Old Town. The Royal Mile runs about a mile from Edinburgh Castle down to the Palace of Holyroodhouse, packing in St Giles’ Cathedral, centuries-old closes, museums, and pubs along one sloping street. You’ll be steps from the castle and able to walk everywhere — the trade-off is steep hills, cobbles, and the liveliest (read: noisiest) evenings in the city. Under the castle rock, the Grassmarket is the Old Town’s going-out quarter, with beer gardens facing the castle walls.
For a genuine splurge, The Witchery by the Castle on Castlehill is nine opulent suites dripping with antiques and oak panelling, about as romantic as Edinburgh gets. A dependable mid-range base is the Radisson Blu Hotel on the Royal Mile at 80 High Street, a full-service four-star right in the thick of it. Families do well at the Apex Grassmarket Hotel, whose upper floors look straight up at the castle. On a budget, the High Street Hostel on Blackfriars Street is a well-run Old Town hostel with dorms and private rooms.
Two experiences are worth booking ahead from an Old Town base: this guided Edinburgh Castle tour with skip-the-line entry (castle tickets sell out in peak season, and the guided grounds tour covers the royal history you’d otherwise miss), and the atmospheric underground vaults walking tour, which descends into the 18th-century chambers beneath South Bridge for the city’s darker stories.
New Town — polished, convenient, calmer at night
North of Princes Street, the New Town is all Georgian symmetry: grand terraces, Charlotte Square, and George Street’s bars and restaurants. It’s the best base if you want elegance without the Old Town’s hills and hubbub — shopping on Princes Street, the Scottish National Gallery, and Calton Hill’s monuments and sunset views are all on your doorstep. Walks down to the Royal Mile take 10–15 minutes through some of the prettiest streetscape in Britain.
The landmark stay is The Balmoral at 1 Princes Street — the clock-tower hotel at the city’s most famous address, all tartan-and-tweed luxury with a Michelin-starred restaurant. The InterContinental Edinburgh The George on George Street is the reliable five-star workhorse, while the Kimpton Charlotte Square brings boutique polish to the square’s townhouses. Newer and design-forward, 100 Queen Street is an Auberge Collection hideaway of just thirty rooms. Budget travellers get one of the best-value sleeps in the centre at Motel One Edinburgh-Royal on Princes Street — stylish, central, and far cheaper than its postcode suggests.
West End & Haymarket — quieter streets, easy transport
West of the centre, the West End mixes Victorian grandeur with theatres and galleries, and it’s noticeably calmer than the Mile at night. Haymarket, around one of the city’s main stations, is the practical choice: quick trains to Glasgow and easy airport access, with full-service hotels at lower rates than a cramped Old Town room. You’re about a 15-minute walk from the Royal Mile.
The grand dame here is the Waldorf Astoria Edinburgh – The Caledonian, the landmark “Caley” at the west end of Princes Street with castle views from its best rooms. For boutique character, The Rutland on Rutland Street pairs twenty-odd stylish rooms with one of the city’s best-regarded restaurants downstairs.
Leith — the food-lover’s waterfront
Edinburgh’s historic port has become its most exciting place to eat. The Shore is lined with pubs, wine bars, and serious restaurants — including Michelin-starred dining — and the Royal Yacht Britannia, the royal family’s former floating palace, is berthed here. The Port of Leith Distillery adds whisky to the waterfront mix. It’s about 25 minutes by bus or tram from the Royal Mile, so it suits travellers who’d rather end the day somewhere with its own scene than in the tourist centre.
The standout stay is Malmaison Edinburgh at Tower Place — a chic, moody boutique conversion right on the waterfront, made for long dinners along the Shore.
Stockbridge & Dean Village — the village-within-the-city pick
If you’d rather feel like a temporary local than a tourist, Stockbridge is the answer: cafés, independent boutiques, and the famous Sunday market, with the Water of Leith walkway and the Royal Botanic Garden on your doorstep. Nearby Dean Village is the prettiest ten minutes in Edinburgh — cobbled streets and old mill buildings along the river, a short downhill walk from the New Town. Hotel inventory is mostly small B&Bs and apartments, which is exactly the point.
Book The Raeburn on Raeburn Place for a proper neighbourhood stay: a handsome townhouse hotel above a beloved local bar and restaurant, right in the middle of Stockbridge life.
Southside & Arthur’s Seat — active days and one grand splurge
South of the Old Town, the Southside is university territory — students, budget restaurants, green spaces — and the gateway to Holyrood Park, where Arthur’s Seat rises 251 metres above the city. The climb takes 45–60 minutes and the payoff is the best panorama in Edinburgh. The Palace of Holyroodhouse sits at the park’s edge, at the foot of the Royal Mile.
This is also where you’ll find Edinburgh’s most storied splurge: Prestonfield House, a 17th-century mansion with peacocks on the lawn and outrageously opulent rooms, in its own grounds at the foot of Arthur’s Seat. At the other end of the scale, the ibis Edinburgh Centre South Bridge is a clean, well-located budget base near the university quarter.
Where I’d stay: the quick chooser
First visit, want it all on foot: the Old Town. Luxury splurge: The Balmoral or Prestonfield House — the two great statement hotels. Elegant and calm: the New Town or West End. Food first: Leith. Local neighbourhood feel: Stockbridge. Watching the budget: Motel One, the ibis on South Bridge, or the High Street Hostel. Whichever you pick, you’re never more than a 20-minute walk from the castle — that’s the joy of Edinburgh’s compact centre.
Practical tips for booking your Edinburgh stay
Book early for August. The Edinburgh Festival Fringe takes over the city every August, and hotel prices soar while availability vanishes — book months ahead if you’re coming then. Getting in: the tram from Edinburgh Airport reaches the city centre in about 30–35 minutes; Waverley station sits right between the Old and New Towns with direct trains from London (around four and a half hours from King’s Cross). Pack for weather, not season: Edinburgh’s forecast changes by the hour — layers and a waterproof beat an umbrella on those cobbles. It’s a walking city: comfortable shoes are non-negotiable, especially in the Old Town.
One evening experience worth booking ahead wherever you stay: a single-malt whisky tasting with storytelling in a bespoke Royal Mile lounge — four drams from Scotland’s whisky regions with the folklore behind them, and non-whisky alternatives if that’s not your drink.
Pairing Edinburgh with the capital? My London in 3 days itinerary covers the essential sights down south, the where to stay in London guide will sort your base there, and London’s hidden gems are worth building a trip around on their own. Edinburgh rewards the traveller who picks the right neighbourhood — choose yours, book early, and bring layers.